Name: Thayer Jewelers
Address: 20 S. Palm Avenue, Sarasota, FL, 34236, US
Telephone: 941-955-8820
Price range: $$

EXPLORE NOW

About Us

Welcome to Thayer Jewelers, since 1982, Thayer Jewelers has sold only the finest heirloom quality jewelry, important colorless & natural fancy color diamonds, gem quality sapphires, rubies, emeralds and rare gemstones.

Thayer Jewelers

New Arrivals

Vintage 14k Yellow Gold Bro...

SKU: 8582

$3,000.00

| /

Vintage 14k Yellow Gold Intricate Carved Floral Coral Brooch / PendantLength: 2.0 inWidth: 1.5 in37.95g
Vintage 18k Gold Angel Skin...

SKU: 8583

$4,500.00

| /

Vintage 18k Gold Angel Skin Coral & Diamond Floral Brooch 45.19g3" x 2.25"
14k Gold Pearl & Diamond Fl...

SKU: 8585

$800.00

| /

14k Yellow Gold Freshwater Pearl and Diamond Brooch, Mid 20th Century. 20.77 grams. By Crescent Silver & Gold Co White freshwater pearls form a...
View full details
GIA Unheated Padparadscha S...

SKU: 8496

$19,000.00

| /

Platinum & 18k rose gold ring with GIA certified 3.06 carat NO Heat Padparadscha sapphire and 2 epolite cut diamonds weighing 0.94 carats. 5.97...
View full details
Wayne Muskett Navaho Inlaid...

SKU: 8595

$950.00

| /

Wayne Muskett Navaho inlaid silver bracelet with Tiger Eye, Jasper and Onyx
Vintage 1940's Rolex Oyster...

SKU: 8594

$1,200.00

| /

Rolex Oyster Precision, ManualVintage 1940's Rolex Oyster Precision Watch. Watch face size: 22 mm. Manual wind
14k Yellow Gold Diamond Ban...

SKU: 8593

$3,800.00

| /

14k Yellow Gold Bangle Bracelet, with 16 round diamonds weighing approximately 0.50 carats, 23.92g
Tiffany Sterling Silver Som...

SKU: 8592

$350.00

| /

Tiffany Sterling Silver Somerset Hoop Earrings with 14k posts. 6.46g 1.25" Length
John Hardy Sterling Silver ...

SKU: 8590

$1,700.00

| /

John Hardy Sterling Silver & 22k Pendant Necklace 66.84g 16 Inches
John Hardy Sterling Silver ...

SKU: 8591

$400.00

| /

John Hardy Sterling Silver Earrings with 22k Gold Hammered Center Total weight 5.92g.
18k Yellow Gold Amethyst Ac...

SKU: 8589

$1,800.00

| /

18k Yellow Gold Amethyst Acorn Pendant on Amethyst bead Necklace 16 inches long. 23.4g
David Yurman MOP Ring

SKU: 8180

$800.00

| /

David Yurman sterling silver and 18k mother of pearl ring, size 6, 23.07 grams
David Yurman MOP Drop Easrr...

SKU: 8175

$1,000.00

| /

David Yurman Sterling Silver drop earrings with mother of pearl. 17.36 grams
Vintage Coral Necklace

SKU: 8588

$2,200.00

| /

14k Yellow Gold Coral Drop Necklace. Cabochon cut. 29.85 grams. 18"
Mid Century 14k Yellow Gold...

SKU: 8587

$400.00

| /

This ring features an coral centerpiece, set in 14k yellow gold. The total weight is 8.01 grams. It is a size 8 and can be resized
18k Victorian Coral Bird Br...

SKU: 8586

$1,000.00

| /

18k Yellow Gold Coral Bird Brooch featuring an coral carving with a white diamond accent weighing 0.20 carats. 25.86 grams. 2.25 inches in length, ...
View full details
Vintage 18k Gold Coral Cam...

SKU: 8584

$1,400.00

| /

Vintage 18k Gold Coral Cameo Brooch 20.45g 1.5" x 1.25"
18k White Gold Chandelier E...

SKU: 7898

$19,500.00

| /

18k White Gold Chandelier Earrings containing 634 round brilliant and Marquis cut diamonds weighing 15.08 carats. 35.33s.
18k White Gold Rolex Ring W...

SKU: 8581

$4,500.00

| /

18k White Gold Rolex Precision Ring Watch. Manual movement. Mid 20th Century. Size 6, Sizable.
14k White Gold Ring with Pi...

SKU: 8572

$4,800.00

| /

14k White gold ring with GIA certified 2.18 carat cushion-cut hot pink sapphire. Half moon-cut white diamonds weighing 0.70 carats. Additional 6 ro...
View full details
14k Amethyst Ring

SKU: 8580

$3,200.00

| /

14k Yellow Gold Ring featuring an Oval Amethyst weighing approximately 35.0 carats. Total weight 26.93 grams. Ring size 7. Sizable.
18k David Yurman Citrine & ...

SKU: 8579

$4,800.00

| /

18k David Yurman ring with checkerboard Citrine and approximately 1.00 carat of round diamonds, size 7,
Retro Movado Cover Watch

SKU: 6672

$6,300.00

| /

18k Retro Period Movado covered watch with diamonds. 52.45g
Retro Ruby & Diamond Watch

SKU: 7633

$3,800.00

| /

14k Hepa Rose & Yellow gold "Retro" period watch with rubies and diamonds. 33.72 grams
Platinum Brazilian Alexandr...

SKU: 8517

$16,500.00

| /

Platinum Pendant with 1.05 carat Brazilian alexandrite and 1.24 carats of diamonds. 8.07g

View All Products

Our Collections

View All Collections

Reviews

What a wonderful experience! We strolled into Thayer Jewelers looking for a vintage engagement ring and found a piece so amazing that I still can't believe it. They stayed open to show me the ring one last time as we were visiting from out of town.

- Julie Schneider

A wonderful place to shop! Jeremy is an expert gemologist and so attentive and accommodating. You can trust that he sells only the highest quality jewelry at fair prices. I have shopped elsewhere and can tell you that the service and quality here are unbeatable!

- Elizabeth Gavin

The owner Jeremy Thayer is deeply knowledgeable about jewelry, specially about rare gems. He has been for many year my go to guy for unique and rare gems. Check out his truly amazing jewelry pieces. You can trust him and his team. You will be in good hands.

- Rodrigo Wolf

Blog posts

August 12, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

How To Figure Out Your Partner's Ring Size Without Asking
The anticipation of popping the question or gifting a ring comes with its own set of challenges. One of the most daunting tasks can be determining your partner's ring size without raising any suspicion. While it might seem like a...
Read now
August 9, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

Engagement Ring Vs. Wedding Ring: What's The Difference?
Engagement and wedding ceremonies have long held prominent places in human cultures across the globe. Integral to these ceremonies are the symbols we cherish: the rings. However, there is a common dilemma for many - understanding the difference between an...
Read now
August 6, 2023 Jeremy Thayer

17 Engagement Ring Styles You Should Know
Choosing an engagement ring is a significant decision in anyone's life. It symbolizes love, commitment, and a future together. Given the importance, selecting a style that resonates with the wearer's personality and preference is crucial. While the market is brimming...
Read now

See more posts

About Us

New Arrivals

Vintage 14k Yellow Gold Bro...

Vintage 18k Gold Angel Skin...

14k Gold Pearl & Diamond Fl...

GIA Unheated Padparadscha S...

Wayne Muskett Navaho Inlaid...

Vintage 1940's Rolex Oyster...

14k Yellow Gold Diamond Ban...

Tiffany Sterling Silver Som...

John Hardy Sterling Silver ...

John Hardy Sterling Silver ...

18k Yellow Gold Amethyst Ac...

David Yurman MOP Ring

David Yurman MOP Drop Easrr...

Vintage Coral Necklace

Mid Century 14k Yellow Gold...

18k Victorian Coral Bird Br...

Vintage 18k Gold Coral Cam...

18k White Gold Chandelier E...

18k White Gold Rolex Ring W...

14k White Gold Ring with Pi...

14k Amethyst Ring

18k David Yurman Citrine & ...

Retro Movado Cover Watch

Retro Ruby & Diamond Watch

Platinum Brazilian Alexandr...

Our Collections

Reviews

Blog posts

How To Figure Out Your Partner's Ring Size Without Asking

Engagement Ring Vs. Wedding Ring: What's The Difference?

17 Engagement Ring Styles You Should Know

Come Vist Our Store

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Added to your cart: